Get $150 off your new puppy! Get coupon here. Personal Delivery to 48 US States

How Do I Pick The Best Puppy From A Litter?

How Do I Pick The Best Puppy From A Litter?

Choosing the best puppy from a litter is an exciting but important decision. A great puppy will fit your lifestyle and bring joy for years, so look for more than just a cute face. Here’s a guide to help you make the best choice:

Know What You Want in a Dog

  • Energy Level – Some dogs are more active and need lots of exercise, while others are content with minimal play.
  • Size & Breed Traits – Research the breed’s temperament, grooming needs, and health tendencies.
  • Lifestyle Compatibility – Do you need a family-friendly dog, a watchdog, or a companion for outdoor adventures?

Assess the Litter’s Environment

  • Look for a clean, well-maintained space—healthy puppies usually come from responsible breeders or well-run shelters.
  • Watch the puppies interact. A healthy litter will be curious, playful, and comfortable with their surroundings.

Evaluate the Puppy’s Health

  • Physical Inspection
    • Bright, clear eyes without discharge.
    • A clean nose, free from mucus or crust.
    • Healthy gums and no bad odor from the mouth.
    • Clean ears with no odor or signs of infection.
    • A shiny coat, free of bald patches or parasites.
  • Movement – Check for limping or stiffness when they walk and play.
  • Weight – Puppies should not look too thin or bloated.

Ask the breeder or shelter for health records and vaccination history.

 Observe Temperament and Behavior

  • Confidence vs. Shyness – A confident puppy will approach new things with curiosity, while a fearful or shy one may struggle with anxiety.
  • Energy Level – Some puppies are more laid-back, while others are high-energy. Choose one that matches your energy level.
  • Socialization Skills – Watch how the puppy interacts with littermates. A puppy that gets along well without being overly aggressive or submissive may have a balanced temperament.

Perform Temperament Tests

Here are a few simple tests you can try…

  • Approach Test – Crouch down and call the puppy. Does it approach confidently, cautiously, or not at all?
  • Handling Test – Pick the puppy up and cradle it. A well-adjusted puppy will relax after a moment, while overly stressed ones may squirm or growl.
  • Noise Test – Clap your hands or drop a small object. Does the puppy recover quickly from the surprise, or does it stay fearful?
  • Play Drive – Offer a toy and see how the puppy responds—some will be enthusiastic, while others may show little interest.

Get Input from the Breeder or Shelter Staff

Experienced breeders or caregivers can offer insights into each puppy’s personality and how it might develop as the dog grows. Ask:

  • Which puppies seem calm, active, or independent?
  • Are there any health or behavioral issues to be aware of?
  • How have the puppies interacted with people and other animals?

Consider the Parents’ Behavior and Health

  • If possible, meet the puppy’s parents or at least the mother. Dogs often inherit temperament traits from their parents. Calm, friendly parents are more likely to produce similar puppies.

Choose With Your Head and Heart

While it’s easy to fall for the most adorable puppy, make sure their temperament fits your lifestyle. Sometimes a calm, unassuming puppy might turn out to be the perfect match rather than the most boisterous one in the litter.

Trust Your Instincts

If a puppy seems off or uncomfortable, trust your gut feeling. Choose the one that feels right for you and your home environment.

Bonus Tip: Prepare for the Puppy’s Homecoming

Make sure your home is puppy-proofed and you have the necessary supplies: food, toys, bedding, and training essentials.

Picking a puppy is the beginning of a lifelong bond. By carefully evaluating temperament, health, and compatibility, you’ll ensure a happier experience for both of you.

Share this article

Related Articles

Get $150 Off Your Favorite Puppy

Get $150 off the purchase of a puppy when you schedule an appointment online!